Saturday, 21 October, 2017

Supreme Court reserves verdict on 'living will' issue

A view of Supreme Court in New Delhi India A view of Supreme Court in New Delhi India
Marlene Weaver | 12 October, 2017, 00:59

After senior advocates Arvind Datar and Sanjay Hegde placed various facets and aspects linking passive euthanasia to living will, advocate Devansh Mohta placed a draft pro forma of a living will or advance directive by a person specifying the medical conditions when s/he should not be provided further artificial life support assistance.

The Centre then told the Bench, also comprising Justices AK Sikri, AM Khanwilkar, DY Chandrachud, and Ashok Bhushan, that it did not support the concept of a "living will" as the "social consequences" would be negative for the country.

Refusing to entertain any doubts on the 2011 judgment in the Aruna Shanbaug case permitting a high court-supervised procedure for passive euthanasia, the bench, also comprising A K Sikri, A M Khanwilkar, D Y Chandrachud and Ashok Bhushan, said: "We can not take a regressive step".

While reserving its verdict, the court has indicated that it may lay down comprehensive guidelines on operationalising the idea of living wills. Especially among the lower middle class, where the elderly are thought of as a burden and hence are subjected to great cruelty.

Disney withdraws 'Jack and the Beanstalk' project
However, the film only pulled in $330 million globally, the lowest total revenue for a Pixar title thus far. We've come to that point, and although it's a hard decision, we are ending active development for now.

Debating the question of law, the Chief Justice then observed that one can not say that you have a right to die (suicide), but you have a right to dignified death. Judicial wisdom is acceptable in pointing the way, but it's up to the Law Commission and the legislatures to ensure proper laws exist whose letter and spirit can't be misused by, say, greedy relatives in ending the lives of sick rich people so that inheritances may be enjoyed sooner. The matter to be decided was whether the law should allow it (euthanasia). "But we recognise that every individual has a right to die with dignity, i.e. the process of end of life must be dignified". Chief Justice Misra said. The judges' sympathy for elders, who may additionally suffer from the greed of relatives, and the value of a human being's life should be upheld even in a "passive euthanasia" situation.

The Court observed that it is essential to determine whether the guidelines postulated in Aruna Shanbaug case is adequate or not. In 2009, author Pinki Virani (who wrote a book on her) filed a petition to allow her to be euthanised.

The top court declined the plea for Shanbaug's mercy-killing but approved the concept of passive euthanasia under exceptional circumstances. This was to resolve the inconsistencies between the Aruna Shanbaug case (which allowed passive euthanasia under certain safeguards), and the Gian Kaur case (which held that the right to life does not include the right to die). In the absence of a law authorizing doctors to do so, they keep incurable patients on life support, he said.

Assisted suicide is when a patient with a competent mind decides to end his or her life with the assistance of a doctor. "This decision is taken by the medical board on the touchstone of modern technology", he observed.

Recommended

  • Portland Hill Asset Management Ltd Increases Stake in PayPal Holdings, Inc. (PYPL)

    After $-1.28 actual EPS reported by Deckers Outdoor Corp for the previous quarter, Wall Street now forecasts -180.47% EPS growth. COPYRIGHT VIOLATION NOTICE: This article was first posted by Dispatch Tribunal and is the sole property of of Dispatch Tribunal.
    How To Hack The Mini SNES To Add More Games

    How To Hack The Mini SNES To Add More Games

    According to Rocket News 24 , the name "Game Boy" wasn't actually part of the trademark filing, but that image is unmistakable. That move seems even more likely as the 30th anniversary of the first Game Boy will happen in 2019.
    Half of the universe's missing normal matter has been found

    Half of the universe's missing normal matter has been found

    Some of the light scatters as it collides with the gases particles, leaving a tiresome patch in the cosmic microwave background. He said the studies go "a long way" in showing that many of our fundamental ideas about space appear to be right.
  • People go to Twitter to see if Facebook and Instagram are down

    People go to Twitter to see if Facebook and Instagram are down

    Facebook , which also owns Instagram , wrote on its developer site: "We are now experiencing an increased level of API errors". The independent website that tracks site outages also reports that Instagram is experiencing user outages as of 11:05 a.m.
    Danny Rose set to snub Chelsea and leave Tottenham for Manchester United

    Danny Rose set to snub Chelsea and leave Tottenham for Manchester United

    Lamela has been missing for even longer, having picked up a hip problem that has prevented him from playing since October 25 past year .
    Watch a Remote-Control Nissan GT-R Take on Silverstone

    Watch a Remote-Control Nissan GT-R Take on Silverstone

    Six computers also connected everything together and were able to make adjustments up to 100 times per second. Four robots inside the auto controlled the steering, transmission, throttle and brakes.
  • Attorney Lisa Bloom Planned To Discredit Harvey Weinstein's Accusers

    Attorney Lisa Bloom Planned To Discredit Harvey Weinstein's Accusers

    According to anonymous sources, Weinstein settled with at least eight different women over the years. Weinstein apologized for his behaviour and acknowledged that it had "caused a lot of pain".
    Packers' Jordy Nelson adopts baby before Cowboys game

    Packers' Jordy Nelson adopts baby before Cowboys game

    How good has Ezekiel Elliott been to start his National Football League career? "No exceptions, he said, there are no exceptions". It is the strongest statement any owner has made since Trump reignited the anthem controversy weeks prior.
    Amazon Offers Students Prime for $5.49 a Month

    Amazon Offers Students Prime for $5.49 a Month

    Parents receive itemized notifications for every order and can cancel and return any item in accordance with Amazon's policies. Amazon has released a new way for parents to control what their teenage children are buying on the shopping website.
  • Sydney woman picks up shark from rockpool

    Sydney woman picks up shark from rockpool

    Don't believe us? Cop this extraordinary video posted to Facebook by Mel's employer Cronulla Real Estate yesterday . Her video of casually transferring a shark from a pool back into the ocean has left people thoroughly impressed.
    Anupam Kher appointed new chairman of FTII

    Anupam Kher appointed new chairman of FTII

    What truly separates Kher from many of his contemporaries is the ease with which he blended into the "actor-star" persona. Chauhan, whose appointment to the post in June 2015 was opposed by FTII students, demitted office in March 2017.
    'In the event of a nuclear attack': Hawaii University issues ominous warning

    'In the event of a nuclear attack': Hawaii University issues ominous warning

    A photo distributed by the North Korean government shows leader Kim Jong Un at an undisclosed location inspecting a weapon. For students on one US college campus, the threat of nuclear war with North Korea feels a little closer this week.

State may slash Value-Added Tax on diesel, petrol today State may slash Value-Added Tax  on diesel, petrol today The state government has been criticised in the past for having the highest taxes on petroleum products in the country. Maharashtra Finance Minister Sudhir Mungantiwar had termed it as a "Diwali gift" to people of the state.

Google Home Mini Caught Spying Google Home Mini Caught Spying The software fix prevents the activation of the speaker with a touch, which was a feature meant to offer options for activation. Russakovskii's Home Mini review unit was recording everything, and it all happened without his knowledge.

Super Mario Odyssey Gets Amazing Broadway-Inspired Trailer Super Mario Odyssey Gets Amazing Broadway-Inspired Trailer Edge Magazine's latest issue carries world's first Super Mario Odyssey Review , and the final review score is a ideal 10. With the upcoming release of Super Mario Odyssey , a debate has grown over whether Mario is a human being or not.

Liverpool Reportedly Agree To Sell Philippe Coutinho Liverpool Reportedly Agree To Sell Philippe Coutinho It's hardly surprising that Barcelona's interest in Coutinho hasn't wavered. But Dembele has endured a nightmare start to life at the Camp Nou.

Cheapest 4G Smartphone by Airtel-Karbonn to Compete With Reliance JioPhone Cheapest 4G Smartphone by Airtel-Karbonn to Compete With Reliance JioPhone Also, Airtel India is going to give Unlimited Calling and 0.5GB data/day with a Rs. 169 recharge that has a 28 days validity. Through this association, we aim at strengthening our reach with the consumer that resides at the heart of smart telephony.

SpaceX to launch Falcon 9 rocket SpaceX to launch Falcon 9 rocket Up until this point, the climate is looking entirely useful for launch, with a 90 percent chance that conditions will be positive. The rest will keep on being propelled in 10-satellite augmentations throughout the following year, alongside one launch of five.

Trial in MS woman's burning death set to begin Trial in MS  woman's burning death set to begin Chambers, who was found lying next to her burning auto on a back road roughly 3 years ago. "Horrific burns", Mr Champion said. The jury is being sequestered and observers are being screened by metal locators under the steady gaze of entering the court.

Is United Continental Holdings, Inc. (NYSE:UAL) Ready for a Breakout? Based on a recent bid, the stock is trading -18.10% away from it's 52- week high and 32.47% away from its 52 week low. The stock of United Continental Holdings Inc (NYSE: UAL ) earned "Buy" rating by Stifel Nicolaus on Thursday, May 25.

Arby's to release venison sandwiches nationwide, test elk meat Arby's to release venison sandwiches nationwide, test elk meat The company expects the sandwiches to sell out quickly again and is advising people to come early if they want one. The venison sandwiches will be available on Saturday, Oct. 21 in all 3,300 restaurants across the country.

Minnesota's Real ID granted grace period Minnesota's Real ID granted grace period Muszynski said the waiver can be renewed annually through 2020, if the state can demonstrate that it is making efforts to comply. Legislation enacted earlier this year set that deadline for getting the state fully up to speed on Real ID.

Pledge to Impeach Trump, a Key Donor Demands of Democrats Pledge to Impeach Trump, a Key Donor Demands of Democrats Only two USA presidents have ever been impeached by the House of Representatives, and both were later acquitted by the Senate. Green postponed introducing the articles of impeachment following the Las Vegas concert shooting.

Croatia in Elite Group of New UEFA Nations League Competition Croatia in Elite Group of New UEFA Nations League Competition England will be in Pot 2 for the group stage draw of the 2018 UEFA Nations League draw, which takes place on January 24. Perhaps the most important part of the new Nations League is that it offers a route to qualification for Euro 2020.

Trump expected to nominate Kirstjen Nielsen as next DHS head Trump expected to nominate Kirstjen Nielsen as next DHS head President Trump has selected Kirstjen Nielsen, a top White House aide and a former homeland security official in the George W. Former DHS Secretary Tom Ridge - the first person to ever hold the position, which President George W.

Active Morning Movers Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. (NASDAQ:AMD) Active Morning Movers Advanced Micro Devices, Inc. (NASDAQ:AMD) The firm has "Equal Weight" rating given on Friday, August 7 by Barclays Capital. $825,625 worth of Advanced Micro Devices, Inc . Peter Lynch says in his best-selling book, "One Up on Wall Street", that institutional ownership is a negative thing.

IMF's growth projections wrong a lot: EAC-PM Member IMF's growth projections wrong a lot: EAC-PM Member The government pegged the fiscal deficit target at 3.2 per cent for the current fiscal and 3 per cent for the next financial year. Among these are job creation, economic growth, agriculture, social sector and fiscal framework.